Personal Narratives - Walcheren Causeway

Private Frank Holm (Signaler)

Baker Company - - my company - - took the lead.   Captain Clarke, second in command of the company, was in command.  Major Robinson, I assume, was L.O.B. for the operation.  It was late in the evening as we moved single file at five-yard intervals southward down the road to the eastern approach to the causeway.  I was carrying the 18-set.  I had the earphones on but no messages were being passed.  We never passed messages going into action unless it was absolutely necessary, and then the message would be as brief as possible so as not to let the enemy discover  the frequency we were transmitting on.  I normally had one earphone on my ear to listen for messages and the other off my ear so I could hear what was going on all around me.  As we moved out onto the causeway all was quiet and calm.  The road was paved.  To the right of the roadway was the railroad track.   To the left of the roadway it seems the Germans had dug slit trenches at regular intervals.  They were evidently intended to be used for their own defence if necessary.  It was October 31.  I remarked to my partner: "Tonight is Hallowe'en.  I wonder if there are going to be any fireworks?"  The answer came soon enough.  A very few minutes later, at 11:00 p.m., our field artillery started to put down a barrage on known targets such as gun emplacements on the Walcheren shore to support our attack, but the moment our guns opened up the German artillery opened fire on the causeway.

It was devastating fire with high velocity shells coming straight down the roadway, sometimes ricocheting off the pavement.  We had to go to ground.  Captain Clarke and I scrambled into one of those German slit trenches so he could try to assess the situation and communicate with Battalion.  To assess the situation was easier said than done.  The rifle platoons were spread out along the roadway up ahead.  So Captain Clarke told me to stay put till he got back; took his runner Maxwell with him and went forward as fast as possible to check on his platoon officers to see how far their platoons had got and what problems they had run into.

Meanwhile the commanding officer of the battalion, Acting Lieutenant Colonel Ellis, came on the air asking for a situation report.  Captain Clarke having gone up ahead, I had to find the company sergeant major to answer the C.O.  I found him but he didn't have anything illuminating to say except what was obvious, that we were coming under very heavy artillery fire.  I got back to my slit trench where I remained as ordered.

This must have been close to halfway across the causeway.  The slit trench seemed to be solid.  Jerry had been considerate enough to line the sides with bricks.   This must have been done at their leisure, long before the present hostilities.   Little did the Germans know that it would be a life-saving shelter for Canadians.   Besides the high velocity shells, the enemy was firing with heavy artillery.   These were probably coastal guns in permanent emplacements on the island.

Suddenly Captain Clarke and Maxwell appeared from the direction of Walcheren.   They dove into the slit trench.  Maxwell was completely out of breath and made the observation that Captain Clarke was a hard man to keep up with.  Captain Clarke was obviously very tense and understandably so.  He was agonizing about the situation his company was in and about what to do next.  However, he got himself together, took the microphone and spoke directly to the colonel, giving him a full report on the deployment of his platoons and what we were up against.

At some point the Germans discovered our wireless frequency and proceeded to jam it.  All I could hear then was a loud EEE-YOW-EEE-YOW-EEE-YOW.  When that happened the control set at Battalion (HQ) would start sending out a netting signal on our first alternative frequency, which is what happened.  Then I had to tune in my receiver to Battalion, net my transmitter to my receiver and call up Battalion to see if they could hear me: "Hello Mike Two, report my signals, over."  If they could hear me loud and clear I would get the message: "Mike Two, strength five, out."  Messages had to be brief.    The 'Mike' was part of our battalion call number for the day; 'two' meant Baker Company; 'strength five' meant loud and clear and 'out' meant end of conversation, no reply expected.

We had to change frequencies several times on the Causeway.  It was usually like that.  On a quiet night with nothing going on the 18-set was good for clear communication for about twelve to fifteen miles, but as soon as you went in on an attack there would be a lot of static from vehicles and explosions and probably Jerry would jam your frequency.  It became difficult to maintain communication over one or two miles, let alone twelve miles.  I believe that there on the Causeway, as on other occasions, the problem of maintaining communications helped me to keep my sanity.  I was so busy with this task that to some extent it took my mind off what was going on around me.

The night passed and morning came.   Baker Company headquarters remained where it was.  The shelling continued.   The heavy shells were the worst.  The explosion would send a shock through you that would reach the very depth of your nervous system and put in doubt your ability to take it.  But once in a while one would land in the soft mud flats beside the Causeway, sink in the mud and fail to explode.  You could feel the ground shake as it dug in.  With this continuous bombardment I was about at the limit of what my nerves could take.

There was a bit of relief though.   We did have some air support in this operation.  On several occasions 'Typhoons' flew over and fired rockets at the heavy gun emplacements on Walcheren.   The Jerries must have taken cover because the shelling would cease for several minutes and we would be able to get out of our trenches and cheer and shout defiance at the enemy.  But the guns were not silenced.  As soon as the 'Typhoons' had completed their attack the Germans resumed the bombardment. tiffie.jpg (15492 bytes)

A heavy shell hit awfully close.  When I looked up I saw nothing but black.   I thought for a moment that I had had it; but it was only a shower of mud and dirt that came down and there was a wheelbarrow sticking out over the end of the trench.   Where that wheelbarrow came from I will never know.  I hadn't seen it before.   At this point I swore that if I ever got out of this hellish place I wouldn't mind eating dirt for the rest of my life.

Captain Clarke spent a lot of time up ahead with the platoons, but from time-to-time would need to pass messages over the wireless.  We would call down artillery fire on enemy positions on Walcheren.  I would say, for example, "Hello Able Two, message for Shelldrake, Mike Roger 242703, Mike target, fire, over." 'Mike Roger' was a code word for map reference and 'Shelldrake' was the code word for artillery.   Within a few seconds we could hear the gun reports from the eith twenty-five pounders of one battery of field artillery and I would receive the message: "Hello Able Two, shot, send corrections, over."  Then we would hear the shells whistling overhead and the detonations on the enemy target.  It was very reassuring.   If I called for a 'Yoke' target all twenty four guns of the 5th Field Regiment would fire.  It was my understanding  that we could also call for a 'Queen' target, in which case all the artillery in Second Division would open up.  By my calculation at the time that would be eighty guns, that is, three field regiments plus one regiment of medium artillery.  All this was available because for a short time we were the lead company of the lead battalion of the lead brigade of Second Division.

Once, where I was, a young rifleman dropped into my trench; I didn't know where he came from.  We talked a bit.  He looked distraught and bewildered.  All of a sudden he turned pale, peeled off his equipment and said: "I'm getting out of here!"  He climbed out and headed eastward off the causeway.  The poor guy had lost his nerve.  He had cracked.

...At one point a shell hit very close to me and the explosion did something to the wireless set.  It went dead and I couldn't find the problem.  Captain Clarke was not there.  What was there to do?  I couldn't just do nothing.  I headed back off the causeway to Battalion HQ to pick up another 18-set.  In my absence, so I was told, Baker Company moved ahead and since they had no signaler, they borrowed the signaler from Dog Company which was moving up behind them so I went in with Dog Company.   As we advanced along the causeway the main problem was the shelling.  I noticed several Canadian dead lying face down in the dirt, wearing the insignia of the Canadian Black Watch.  They must have been casualties of the Black Watch assault of the previous afternoon.

D Company headquarters advanced as far as a huge crater about two-thirds of the way along the causeway.  It pretty well cut the causeway in two.  The Germans must have blown the hole to prevent vehicles from crossing.  Dog Company headquarters took up a position in the crater.  Baker Company HQ must have been up very close to the island.  Where Able Company and Charlie Company were I had no idea at the time.   Sometimes, as I have said, it was difficult to know the complete picture, especially at night.  It was hard enough to do your job and keep track of the few people around you.  Later that night Baker Company and Dog Company were relieved by other units and moved back off the causeway.  That was the night of the first of November.

...When B Company gathered the next morning we counted about sixty out of about one hundred who went in on the attack.  That meant that B Company alone suffered about forty casualties...

Taken from A BACKWARDS GLANCE: The Personal Story of an Infantry Signaller with the Calgary Highlanders in World War II by Frank P. Holm (Sault Ste Marie, ON, 1989)

Private George Teasdale (Rifleman)

The next day, after the rest of the regiment came up, we moved to the entrance of the causeway.  A lot of the young kids were getting upset.  It was pretty awesome.   The Germans were firing shells from the other end, bouncing them off the road, and they were ricocheting back and forth all over the place.  But the attack had begun.   We moved out early in the morning, onto the road, and found a lot of dead bodies from the regiment that had been in ahead of us.  As soon as we started to run, the firing began, and I can still remember the Mad Major yelling, "Come on, you sons-of-bitches!"  We got all seperated.  At one point, an armoured bulldozer came along to try to fill in a ditch that had been blasted across the centre of the causeway, but it drew heavy fire and had to back off.

teasdale.jpg (24648 bytes)

I think I got close to the other side, but I don't know how close.  When I had worked my way forward, I jumped into a crater and found a major from another company.   There were a half dozen bodies lying in the hole.  The major asked me who I was and where I had come from.  When he saw me peering over the edge, he told me to stay put.  We talked a bit about the attack, and he was obviously upset.  Things had gone wrong.

After a while, my own company's commanding officer and a platoon lieutenant crawled up beside us.  They looked into the crater, spotted me and the major, and yelled at us to go with them.  The major grabbed my shoulder and told me again to stay where I was.  The other officers went on.  The next thing I know, there was a hell of a commotion and back they came, both of them hurt, dragging each other.  That's how far they had gone.  We couldn't move ahead.  Anyway, the battle lasted the whole day, and when the night came, somebody crawled up beside us to call us back.  I remember getting off the causeway - I was out of it.  We were a sorry looking bunch.

Text and photo taken from A LIBERATION ALBUM: CANADIANS IN THE NETHERLANDS 1944-45 by David Kaufman and Michiel Horn. (The Bryant Press Ltd, 1980 (ISBN 0-07-092429-5))

 
Captain F.H. Clarke (Acting Company Commander)

For manoeuvring, we had just the space between the top of the dyke and the water back of it.  When the tide came in, it wasn't very much.  The enemy were using 81 mm mortars on us, at less than fifty yards range.  They were dug in on the land side of the floodbank and we were on the water side.

....We were strung out in a long thin line, and couldn't do anything; we couldn't move one way or another.  Each time we tried to go over the dyke we took a hell of a beating.  About this time Jerry launched a counterattack at the end of the causeway, at our point of contact with D Company...

D Company was being forced back; that would leave us exposed at both ends - our rear was now in danger...and eventually we moved back behind the crater in the middle of the causeway and held on.

 
Major Ross Ellis (Acting Battalion Commander)
(Webmaster's comments in blue)
(Interviewer's questions in green)

I think they called it Woensdrecht, but it was a coffin-shaped piece of property we opened up.  That's what started the move up the Scheldt.  It wasn't Hoogerheide that opened it.  It was the one in the middle of October that opened up the Causeway up to the Scheldt.

coffin.gif (6732 bytes)

ellis.jpg (10310 bytes)

"Why was (the Causeway) attacked the way it was?"

At that time, on orders from corps and division and so on, we went in.   The intelligence information on that was about as bad as anything we ever got.

We were directed to go in there, pull into the main city, which was Middelburg, take it, and we were told that there were some 350 "white bread" cases, ulcer cases.  In other words, just a kind of semi-hospital unit of the Germans holding that as a base and no ability to fight or anything.  They kicked the hell out of us and they did with the (British) Mountain Division (the inaptly named 52nd Lowland Division) that went in after us.  They eventually came in from the south from Flushing with many, many times the troops we had.   They came in from Westkapelle into...Middelburg. 

Another thing was that in the intelligence reports was that we couldn't go on the land attack across where the canal was supposed to be because it was so bad.  The only way we could do it was to cross on that causeway.   It was ultimately found out that we could have gone across in a number of places without the slightest difficulty, spread our troops out and been much more successful than we were.  These are the things that are a bit disturbing.

It was an awesome situation trying to advance up that damn Causeway.

You put a bunch of guys in a cannon, push them up to the mouth, tell them to spread when they get to the mouth of the cannon, and that's about the time the thing goes off.  So it was a bad deal.

(Question: "In your history I was reading the George Hees went up and took over "A" Company.  I was talking to him...he was very fuzzy about this.")

George has got reason to be fuzzy about it.   Knobby (Captain F.H.) Clarke was in Toronto when George ran as (a candidate for Member of Parliament).  He was having a little trouble so he brought his war record into it.  The way it read on that particular case: he went up, took over the company, and sorted out the whole bloody Calgary Highlanders/5th Brigade.  He got them into battle order and pretty near won the battle by himself.

He has changed his story.  He said he led this platoon or (a) small company of (Le Regiment de) Maisonneuve and he didn't lead the Calgary Highlanders.

That's not correct.  It was quite a thing for him to come in...because he had come up from Tac HQ from Brigade to get a progress report.  He was wearing a staff cap which he always wore, the ordinary officer's cap.  He then said, "Well, I'll go up and take over a company because I've lost two company commanders and a couple of platoon commanders.  Wynn Lasher and Shoning had been wounded.  I'll go up."  He called back to the Brigadier and the Brigadier said "sure", so we got him a tin hat and took one of the scouts to take him out and show him how to run a Bren Gun.

I took him up onto the Causeway.  He didn't lead any Maisonneuve across.  During the night he got shot in the arm.   What he did was very commendable because it took a lot of guts for a guy who had never been in action to go into a hell-hole like that one.  George spoke to the unit at one of the reunions and was well-received.  That was a stinky-hole and we were finally relieved by a British Mountain (Division)...the 52nd Division.

What part did the Maisonneuve play?

The Maisies - they backed us up and were supposed to at one point go through us.  Dalt Heyland was partway up the Causeway and then came back to his company.  They were a bit startled that somebody up there was shooting at them.  It wasn't a good place for any of us, really.  They sort of make out that they were the people that took the Causeway.

The Maisonneuves?

Yes.

That's not correct.

I'm sure it isn't.  They probably took it and kept it.  We were the only ones that took it and put troops onto Walcheren Island itself.  We lost Johnny Moffat in there. (Lieutenant John David Moffatt was killed on 1 November at Walcheren Causeway, aged 25). That was the only place I saw Germans using flamethrowers on our troops.  John's group went off the end of the Causeway, went south, and got involved with the German flamethrowers at that point.   The Germans from down near Flushing were firing those 9-inch guns which made a hell of a hole.

That whole battle was a real tough one.   From a Canadian point of view, nobody has really written anything about it.   It was principally a Canadian battle.  The Brigade came in at the last to take over Flushing.  That lasted about 5 or 6 days.  But the battle down in Breskens, the battle in South Beveland, lasted pretty nearly 20 days.

It was a Canadian operation.  It was one that I think ultimately led to the opening up of that entire area and the shortening of the supply lines and everything else.

That was essential.

But the actual battle itself in which the Calgary Highlanders took part didn't develop a great deal  The main accomplishment we got out of there was we got as many as we could out alive.  We did a very commendable job as far as our guys were concerned.  It was the way the Highlanders went all the time; they got a job and went at it.

It was so essential that Antwerp be open because the logistic situation was so bad and they were trying to move the supplies 400 miles from the Normandy beachhead.

I took over after we went into Hoogerheide.   I had command of the unit for Woensdrecht for the Walcheren battle and after we opened that up, (Lieutenant General) Guy Simonds (commander of II Canadian Corps and sometimes acting commander of First Canadian Army) came up and congratulated the Calgaries on doing that because we were the last of four or five regiments that tried it.  (The Black Watch, for one,  had suffered terrible casualties at the Coffin on what they called Black Friday, 13 October 1944).  Guy came up and I was acting CO with the information that there was somebody already on the way up (from France) to take over (the battalion)... Then I had to (take the) unit up through Beveland and onto Walcheren Island.  Then we were pulled out of there and went back to Hieres(?).  Two days later I was the Colonel which made me quite happy?

From a telephone interview dated 21 August 1982